Saturn LoftAdd Saturn Loft as a friendSaturn Loft will be notified and will have to accept this friendship request, to view updates from Saturn Loft and their ratings you must follow them. |
About me
Nerd. 35, Female, United StatesOccupation: Writer & artist
Lists
1 votes
Favorite Music Artists
(21 items)Person list by Saturn Loft Last updated 11 years, 2 months ago
|
Recent reviews
Alexander: Child of a Dream review

This is one of those easy reads, so easy to read in fact, that it tends not to linger very long in the mind after finishing the last page.
The historical component of the book is actually pretty decent. The author did his research and it shows, but he also doesn't overload the reader with details to demonstrate his encyclopedic knowledge of all things Macedonian. That's refreshing.
However, he tones down the homoerotic relationship between Hephaestian and Alexander. They seem more like Super Good Innuendo Friends with a bit of touching (done tastefully behind the scenes of course). The problem with this is that it doesn't illustrate the kind of relationship that would cause Alexander to go absolutely mad with grief when Hephaestian died later on. The author doesn't really manage to sell us this.
Likewise, Alexander's own personality doesn't really come through. He was clearly a very driven, passionate, and volatile person, but aside from the occasional tantrum in this book we don't see much of it. (Maybe we'll get to more of that in the next volume.)
So- decent historical read, just not particularly memorable.
PS: I thought the author was at his best during a certain assassination scene. Well-written and perhaps the one truly striking bit in the book.

Occidental Mythology (Masks of God) review


The Three Theban Plays: Antigone/Oedipus the King/Oedipus at Colonus review

1 - ANTIGONE: Antigone is the daughter of Oedipus and heir to her family's persistent dark cloud of misfortune. She wants to bury her equally-unlucky brother but her loyalty to her doomed brethren may cost her. (Of course it will! It's Sophocles!)
2 - OEDIPUS THE KING: Oedipus is the best king for miles around and everyone knows it, including him.* Unfortunately an ominous stain is creeping into his idyllic kingdom; a plague is raging and it seems the gods are upset about something or other. The only person who seems to know what's up is a blind prophet and he's got some bad news for poor Oeddy.
3 - OEDIPUS AT COLONUS: The action in this place takes place between the events of Oedipus the King and Antigone. This the most philosophical of the trilogy, dealing with ideas of fate, guilt, and redemption. (I thought it was a bit boring.)
* Uh oh! Hubris!

The Last of the Wine review

Anyway, this book takes place during a particularly fascinating era in Ancient Greek history, the time of the Peloponnesian War. The city of Athens had reached its highest point and after the war it would never again be what it was. The characters in this book do not know that however, and that's what makes the story so bittersweet and compelling.
Bonus appearances from Socrates and his associates provide extra flavor for those who like a bit of philosophy in their fiction. Others will be annoyed by the pontificatory tangents. Once again, it's a matter of taste.
Also, since this is a Renault book, you should know that the romantic love of two young men is a central plot point. I personally find it refreshingly unconventional. (It certainly was refreshingly unconventional in 1956 when this novel was first published! Mary Renault deserves approbation for being a trailblazer in LGBT fiction, but if you have problems with the subject you can skip it. You will be missing out on top-notch historical fiction though.)

Funeral Games review

Funeral Games kind of suffers from the same problem. Without a strongly-rendered main character to provide focus and cohesion it just doesn't have the same enthralling quality as the first 2 books. As a novel with an ensemble cast, it isn't bad, and you get a decent picture of the historical happenings that the fictional story is built on... but it just seems a bit superfluous.
(This just squeaks by with an 8 out of 10, because it's still well above average quality for an historical novel. Definitely the weakest in the trilogy, though.)

The Persian Boy review

The narrator of The Persian Boy is Bagoas (based on a real historical person), who was a favorite of Persian king Darius III and went on to become the erรดmenos or beloved of Alexander the Great. Not much is known about him beyond that but Renault makes him into a very real character, with his own passions and motivations.
The perspective on Alexander the Great is also very interesting. Not everyone may agree with Renault's interpretation, but never-the-less, this is quite possibly the most nuanced and thorough fictional rendering of a very mysterious and complex man.
The complicated emotional triangle between Alexander, Bagoas, and Hephaestion is adroitly imagined. There is some definite homosexuality, some sensuous scenes of such, but nothing particularly explicit.
It's not all psychological drama though, there's plenty of action and colorful battle scenes to keep the reader turning pages. As historical novels go, this one is well above average.

Gates of Fire: An Epic Novel of the Battle of Thermopylae review


The Bull from the Sea review

Also: Renault jarred me a bit at the end by having one of her dying characters utter the immortal last words of Socrates: not "I drank what?", but that mundane bit about owing someone a rooster. It ruined what would have been a nice dramatic scene for me because I immediately recognized the cribbed phrase. Bad Renault! No cookie for you.

The King Must Die: A Novel review


D'Aulaires' Book of Greek Myths review


Books
Favorite - View all |
![]() ![]() |
Music
Top rated |
![]() ![]() |
Movies
Top rated |
![]() ![]() |
My feed

"I'm glad to see this. I found this artist on the web awhile ago and loved her stuff, but then forgot her name and couldn't find her again..."

"Great list. I especially liked the DiCaprio Crying Collage. Also the James Van Der Beek pic is hilarious, although I really shouldn't mock a man's tears..."

"1. Cider With Rosie by Laurie Lee 2. Housekeeping by Marilynne Robinson 3. American Ruins: Ghosts on the Landscape by Maxwell MacKenzie 4. In The Absence of the Sacred by Gerry Mander 5. Watershi"

"Great list! Volcano made me mad. I live in Southern California and that movie made no geological sense at all. Also, I felt the same way about What the Bleep? Intriguing ideas, very poor execution. Th"

"The comment about Amelie made me laugh. Really enjoyed this list!"

"Great list! Synesthesia is a fascinating gift and really interesting to see how different people experience it."
Welcome to Listal!